Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Holly Coy

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

State Farm® Insurance Agent

Holly Coy

12342 Shelbyville Road
Louisville, KY 40243-1471

Next to US Bank & Popeyes in the Middletown Plaza.

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Holly Coy

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5:30pm
9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call or text us 24 hours a day!


12342 Shelbyville Road
Louisville, KY 40243-1471


English, Spanish

Welcome to Holly Coy State Farm Agency!

Did you know State Farm offers Life Insurance? It’s important to learn the options that are available so you can ensure your family is protected. We pride ourselves on having a comprehensive conversation to make sure we are providing you the right policy for your budget. Contact us today to discuss your options!

Our office is located in the Middletown Plaza behind Popeyes on Shelbyville Rd. in Middletown, KY.

I am a long-time resident of Kentucky, moving to Louisville from Bardstown 9 years ago. I have been part of the State Farm family since 2010 where I began my career as an Agent Team Member. I worked for a few agents over the years before opening my own office January 1, 2021. I absolutely love the opportunity I have been given to make a difference in the lives of others while bettering the community I live in and serve. When I am not at the office, you can find me spending time with my husband, Jeff, and our kids. We love to travel; Vegas and the Smoky Mountains are our favorite places to visit.

I am a member of the Middletown Chamber of Commerce and highly involved in our community. My team and I have over 35 years of combined experience providing customer service & insurance products. My agency has been recognized for our outstanding customer service from our customers, the community and State Farm. We have earned State Farm Honor Club 3 years in a row, State Farm Ambassador Travel Club twice, 2023 Community Choice Award for the top Insurance Agency in Louisville as well as being nominated again for the 2024 Top Insurance agency and Top Boss Award. Whether you are looking for car insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance, business insurance or life insurance, we are here to help you get the coverage for your specific needs. My team and I are passionate about helping and educating people to ensure they are prepared when the unexpected occurs. We want to be there on our customers worse day emotionally, to make it a better day financially and to ease their mind.

Community Involvement:

  • We love to sponsor and participate in local events such as the Chamber events, festivals, Back-to-School events & sporting events.

  • Supporting other small businesses in the area with our Small Business Showcase.

  • We partner with Make-A-Wish for our Quotes for Good program. A local charity that is near and dear to my heart. Get a quote and help us donate to the charity to allow them to continue granting wishes for critically ill children.

  • We sponsor Children's Miracle Network Hospitals anytime we have the opportunity to. We sponsored a Summer Kick-off concert benefiting CMN and participated in the golf scramble in October to benefit CMN as well.

  • We sponsor Kentucky Safe Driver annually with their Drive4Teens Golf tournament. Such an amazing organization that strives to continue reducing fatal injury collisions through education and public awareness for teen drivers.

  • Giving back to the community is very important to our agency. We partner with local schools to host an Angel Tree for Christmas each year. It is always a huge success and so rewarding to know we are able to help families see smiles on their children's faces Christmas morning.

  • In December we host our Annual Donuts with Santa event. We always have special appearances, donuts & hot chocolate, presents for all and crafts for the kids to decorate and take home. Be sure to follow us on social media for information on the Donuts with Santa 2024! It is definitely an event that you don't want to miss.

Call, text, email, or stop by today for an insurance quote. We provide free quotes for the following services:

  • Auto Insurance

  • Homeowners Insurance

  • Business Insurance

  • Life Insurance

  • Motorcycle Insurance

  • Boat Insurance

  • Off-road Insurance

  • Motorhome Insurance

  • Renter's Insurance

  • Supplemental Health coverage

  • Liability Insurance

  • Pet Insurance

  • Retirement

  • Rocket Pro

As May blossoms with new beginnings, it's an ideal time to refresh your insurance program. Whether you're celebrating graduations, preparing for summer vacations, or simply enjoying the spring blooms, ensuring your insurance policies are up-to-date is crucial. Take a moment this month to review your coverage, from life insurance to home and auto policies. As life transitions and seasonal activities unfold, having the right insurance protection in place can provide invaluable peace. Reach out to us today for a personalized insurance review and make this May a month of proactive policy structuring and protection.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products


Time to break these bad driving habits

Keep yourself and others safe on the road by kicking these bad driving habits to the curb.

Share the road with farm vehicles

Rural road driving might feel safe & relaxing but they are shared with farm vehicles & have risks. Here are tips to help when driving in the country.

When can you leave kids home alone?

If your child insists they don't need a babysitter, knowing the rules around latchkey children and leaving kids at home alone is important.

View More Articles
Our mission is to establish and maintain strong relationships with our State Farm customers and to foster renewal business. My team is committed to providing excellent customer service and insurance products that provide high quality and coverage, while creating a reputation in the community for our honesty and integrity.

At Holly Coy State Farm Agency, our team has over 60 years of combined customer service and insurance experience. We pride ourselves on our dedication to providing customers with exceptional service. Not only are we professional but also friendly and eager to get to know our customers. We have multiple bilingual ladies as well. Whether you are in the market for Auto, Home, Life, Health or Business insurance needs, our experienced team is always ready to assist you. Give us a call, someone is always available!

our team image 0 our team image 1 our team image 2
Yelina Rodriguez State Farm Agent Team Member

Yelina Rodriguez

Office Manager

I was born in Cuba and moved to Florida when I was 17. I have been in Louisville since September of 2020. I have been with Holly Coy State Farm since August of 2021. I enjoy meeting new people and helping protect them and their families against the unexpected. I began my career in the insurance industry 6 years ago and love every minute of it. I have met so many great people along the way and been able to help so many when they needed it the most. In my free time I love traveling, hiking, painting and paddle boarding.

Cori Clark State Farm Agent Team Member

Cori Clark

Office Associate

I am from Oldham County KY. I'm a very family-oriented person and love spending time with my fiancé Jamie and our daughter Ava. I started my career in the insurance industry in November 2022 with Holly Coy and love helping people protect their assets and family. We never know what tomorrow will bring and I want to be there for you in the good times and the bad times.

Shealee Coy State Farm Agent Team Member

Shealee Coy

Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep

Born & raised in Glasgow, KY but I recently relocated to Bardstown with my husband Michael & our son, Lyric. I am new to the industry but have years of customer service experience and find helping people the most rewarding part of my job. I love meeting new people and would love the opportunity to not only assist you with your auto and home insurance but build a lifelong relationship with your family.

Madison Castello State Farm Agent Team Member

Madison Castello

Customer Service Representative

I am from Campbellsville, KY but moved to Louisville in June of 2021 and have been with Holly Coy State Farm ever since. I enjoy helping people with their auto, home, and renters insurance, educating people on insurance and helping people protect what's most important! I am currently a University of Louisville student! When I am not working or in school, all of my time is spent with my husband, Noah, and our dog, Hudson!

Molly Ann Daniel State Farm Agent Team Member

Molly Ann Daniel

Customer Service Representative

I was born & raised in Floyd's Knobs, IN but now live in Southern KY. I enjoy spending time with my husband, our three year old son & our two dogs. I have been with State Farm for 7 years & have seen this company step up to the plate for it's customers time after time. I am thankful each day to make a difference in our customers lives and ensure your families are properly protected.

Jeff Leftwich State Farm Agent Team Member

Jeff Leftwich

Marketing Director

Jillian Stevenson State Farm Agent Team Member

Jillian Stevenson

Marketing Coordinator

Born & raised in Louisville, a graduate & fan of WKU! I love spending time with family & friends & traveling with my husband. Our favorite places to visit have been Mexico & Ireland. I lived in Savannah, GA and have to say it was probably my favorite place to live. I love meeting new people and helping others anyway I can.
Katy Rodriguez State Farm Agent Team Member

Katy Rodriguez

Staff Assistant

My husband and I moved to Kentucky recently from Holguin, Cuba and welcomed our little girl into the world. I love spending time with my family, traveling and spending time outdoors.
Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.